Publish What You Pay

Posted on August 9, 2007 by Tricia

I’m in Bali learning a whole lot about the “Resource Curse”, where resource rich countries are cursed with minerals, oil and gas but unfortunately are amongst the poorest in the world, mainly due to corruption and mismanagement of funds. Right now Mr. Basir is presenting, from Afghanistan. It’s a great time of learning about technical details such as IFIs (International Financial Institutions) like World Bank etc, EITI (Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative), PWYP (Publish What You Pay) – a coalition of world wide NGOs etc. This conference is to get an Asia-Pacific Regional Coalition going.

I presented yesterday on the Case on Malaysia, mainly investigating the transparency of accounting of oil and gas companies. This includes Petronas, Shell and others. Malaysia has done a whole lot better than some of the other countries being represented here, (Myanmar, Timor Leste etc), but at the same time, there are loopholes that need to be looked into further.

Mainly it is about “publishing how funds are actually being USED”. Watch this space for more interesting news! There’s so much that can be done. And this might just be the answer to many of our woes, Malaysia being OIL and gas rich.

These are some of the issues I highlighted in the presentation on Malaysia yesterday.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

My article in the Star

Posted on August 9, 2007 by Tricia

Genuine unity

A young Malaysian believes in a Malaysia that smiles with her heart.

By TRICIA YEOH

ON Merdeka Day, one is witness to a fanfare of celebrations, semangat muhibbah and flag-flying. This year is no different, and I stand by my fellow patriots in giving full allegiance to this nation we call “home”, because really, this is a home like no other.

Every year, there will be images of ladies impeccably clad in their respective traditional outfits, singing their lungs out to patriotic songs, on television.

Tricia Yeoh: ‘I, like many Malaysians of my generation, naturally trust our leaders to look out for us.’

What perturbs me, however, is that some of these choir singers wear plastic smiles, seemingly disconnected from the songs they sing. Since I first noticed this, I’ve seen many false expressions of unity in the country.

These days I’m in search of something more meaningful.

I, like many Malaysians of my generation, naturally trust our leaders to look out for us.

I am therefore troubled when I hear remarks by a Parliamentarian, no less, that people of my particular skin colour should leave the country and go back to where we belong. Had it not occurred to my dear statesman that this country truly is where we belong and to which we firmly pledge our allegiance?

Establishing the fact that Malaysia is a multi-racial society should be sufficient to convince us that the country must serve all and all alike.

The stinging realisation of practices that discriminate one particular group over another has hit home. Thousands of Malaysians have chosen to migrate, preferring countries that recognise meritocracy first.

I have chosen to work in the area of public policy in Malaysia. I believe that working in the area of public policy gives me a tremendous opportunity to influence change in society on a macro level. I am willing to grasp at straws for the sake of a better tomorrow, even if it takes several generations.

In my work, I have had the opportunity to interact with people of all races, religions, geographical regions and backgrounds. These encounters help to shape public policies on socio-economic issues.

I believe that we must agree upon a culture of inclusiveness and appreciate people for who they are without necessarily placing them in little compartments in our heads.

Only then can we appreciate policies that aim to achieve a greater good for collective gain.

It is also necessary to move beyond artificial displays of unity. People should be given equal treatment, as it is crucial in ensuring that they feel accepted and united.

It is only upon dealing with the two fundamental notions of non-discrimination and equality, that we can begin to grapple with issues such as corruption, inefficiency, unemployment, lack of safety and security, pollution, and other socio-economic problems.

Public policy reform through research, analysis, dialogue and constructive criticism is a long and laborious process, but one that I feel is worth doing.

I believe in a day when this nation will move beyond petty racism and discriminatory practices. I believe in a day when race and religion are not wrongly used as political tools for power gain.

I believe in a Malaysia that celebrates cultural diversity beyond rigid identities of categories, and one that practises genuine unity because it desires to.

I believe in a Malaysia that smiles with its heart. No more lip service, no more plastic smiles, please.

  • Tricia, 24, is a senior research analyst at the Centre for Public Policy Studies. The views expressed are her own.

    • Posted in Personal, Reflections, The Cause | 1 Comment

    A Reader’s Response to Zam’s statement

    Posted on August 9, 2007 by Tricia

    A reader’s response to Info Minister Zam
    Time to stop believing your own propaganda

    Dear Sir,

    I refer to your August 3 report on the comments made by the Minister of Information in response to the launch of the Merdeka Statement.

    On the contrary, I believe it is the Honourable Minister that needs a healthy reality check. If theSun‘s report is correct, I am astonished that barely within 24 hours of the launch of the Merdeka Statement he has managed to consult the majority of the people in this country and, having consulted them, he has come to the conclusion that the majority of the people in this country are offended by the first item of the Merdeka Statement.

    Be that as it may, the world doesn’t live in Malaysia. We do. The world has an outsider’s view of racial unity in Malaysia. We live the reality on a daily basis. Yes we did enjoy the spring of greater racial unity in the earlier years of our lives. But as we get older we now experience the increasing winter of discontent, and our concerns have grown for the future of our children, and our children’s children, in the next 50 years. If the unity of our country is not in trouble, why have there been press reports (which have not been challenged) about the increase in racial polarisation in our schools and universities?

    Why has there been a flight from the sekolah kebangsaan to the sekolah jenis kebangsaan? If the unity of our country is not in jeopardy, why was there a need to start National Service? So that our youths could play around with M16 rifles? If the unity of our country has not been under threat, why is it that we actually have a Parliamentary Select Committee on Unity and National Service looking into issues of national unity, having public hearings, compiling a report, etc.

    Why was the Jabatan Perpaduan Negara re-named Jabatan Perpaduan Negara dan Integrasi Nasional? The 42 organisations which were listed as supporting (whether in whole or in part) the Merdeka Statement either deal with or represent ordinary people of all walks of life on an everyday basis. Does the Honourable Minister really think that the Federation of Malaysian Consumer Associations is elitist? Or the Malaysian Confederation of the Disabled? Or Yayasan Strategik Sosial? This last organisation is a body that works with underprivileged and marginalised, mainly Indian, children and youths. How more “un-elitist” can you get?

    Does he consider the Malaysia Hindu Sangam elitist? Or the Malaysian Buddhist Association? Rather than face the reality, the preferred response appears to be to classify these groups as an elitist unrepresentative fringe group, and then to dismiss them as “Irrelevant!”

    Furthermore, when you actually take a look at the Merdeka Statement, is it so bad that under the first item there is a call to ensure that “all new policies should be tested against the tenets of the Federal Constitution and the Rukun Negara? Is it so horrible that “an independent and transparent National Consultative Council on Vision 2020 should be established immediately? Is it so intolerable that “a National Research Institute on Ethnic Relations should be established?” Are these things, in and of themselves, so repugnant to the average person in the street that the majority of Malaysians would be offended by such suggestions?

    And finally, what is so objectionable about the setting up of a truth and reconciliation committee, designed to listen to people, talk about their personal experience of nation-building, of instances where government action or policy has, instead of bringing good,
    caused hurt and pain. It would be ordinary people sharing their stories, recounting their difficulties, letting the rakyat speak for themselves. There are so manythings that we are not allowed to talk about, so many things that are the subject of threats of prosecution or incarceration, or actual gag orders.

    Why would a Minister of Information consider a suggestion of hearing directly from the rakyat something which is “uncalled for”? If it shatters the picture postcard image of Malaysia that his ministry tries so hard to portray, that is unfortunate. He should not believe his own propaganda.

    Andrew Khoo
    Kuala Lumpur
    via email on Aug 4, 2007

    Posted in The Cause | Leave a comment

    3 Stations in the Qur’an

    Posted on August 5, 2007 by Tricia

    I was graciously taught these concepts by a good friend. Themes are very similar between the Bible and the Qur’an.

    There are three stations that mankind goes through as one travels through life. These three capture the struggle and innermost desires of a person.

    1. Nafs al-amarah bi al-su’

    This is the stage at which the bestial, carnal nature of man overrides all else. Desires, wants, lust, greed epitomise man at this point, where actions are driven by selfish nature and focus is upon self. This is the “nafs” that animals and human beings share.

    2. Nafs lawamah

    Based on the assumption that morality is inherent, this is the station at which humans are able to now exercise a level of conscience, and hence a struggle ensues between one’s desires and will. This struggle continues in the continuous desire to strike a balance. This is the stage at which most of us are presently in.

    3. Nafs al-mutmainah

    This is the final stage which most will not be able to achieve, the desired station where it takes no effort whatsoever to do good in life. Goodness is therefore the chosen natural action, needing no struggle nor the pricking of conscience upon one’s will.

    Jesus, in calling the Pharisees to think instead upon the spirit of the law as opposed to the letter of the law, said to them that the most important commandment was to “Love the Lord, your God, with all your heart and mind and soul”, and the next was to “Love your neighbour as yourself”. These were spoken in opposition to regimented law of archaic nature, performed very much for the sake of it at the time. Inherent within this teaching is the call towards Nafs al-mutmainah. The natural desire to engage in doing good, which is a result of naturally loving one and the other. Different religions have taught these principles in different terminologies.

    I am admittedly within the Nafs lawamah category at this point.

    Posted in Religion, Theology | 1 Comment

    Elections is for the Malays?

    Posted on August 5, 2007 by Tricia

      Khairy J. is at it again. He says that the elections is for the future of the Malays. Of course. It is plain to see. Race card played once again for political mileage. Enough said. No need any indepth political analysis, this one, let’s not reduce ourselves to pretend that it warrants any philosophical consideration.

    Instead, No. 2 of my postings of what I wish the Prime Minister would say. Or anyone from UMNO, for that matter. I wish we had a noble statesmen who would say the following:

    “Young man, I thank you for your enthusiasm. Indeed, it is honourable that you would desire to stand for the people of your kind. We no doubt need intelligent, passionate men as yourself to uplift the sorry state of our Malay brethren – especially those who are still economically disadvantaged. I agree with you.

    However, you see, even our Founding Fathers and many great leaders that followed, have established an understanding that Malaysia is really for people of different ethnic groups. We share common ground that is this nation. We share a common space, a common value system. We share Malaysia. To say that the coming elections is for the future of the Malays alone is not a fair representation of our collective history. Of course yes, it IS for the future of the Malays but also for the future of all other races – Malaysia is made up of other races as well, and they form a pretty large group of people here. Plus, don’t forget that the Chinese and Indians also helped in the process of Independence and fighting the Japanese Occupation.

    So I think, it is better if you said this: Elections is for the sake of all Malaysians, to ensure they get the leaders of their choice, responsible leaders who, in demonstrating the best of integrity and governance can then contribute to the elevation of people in society as a whole, Malays included. I think that is a better way of putting it. Could you please apologise to our fellow Chinese and Indian and other brothers and sisters for your statement? Let’s show them that we really do welcome them as they welcome us. I think it is only fair that they have an equal say in the future of our country. After all, we are all living together. They are equal citizens too.”

    When and from WHOM can we receive such a statement?

    I’m waiting for a noble statesmen to gently admonish racism without being arrogant or confrontational.

    I’m waiting for a noble Malay politician and leader to be bold and brave – plus, it is being righteously bold, about something that is true and noble. The future lies in your hands. A mere Chinese nobody like me (or my fellow Chinese leaders, for that matter) has no voice, I feel. Our mouthpieces are weak.

    I’m waiting. I’m waiting. I’m waiting.

    Posted in The Cause | 3 Comments

    A Language of Persuasion

    Posted on August 5, 2007 by Tricia

    Those who had urgent messages for the people of a nation cowed under by darkness and doom shared one thing in common: their ability to go down to the level of the people and speak in a language they understood.

    Their hearts were equally heavy, perturbed by the situation which seemed unending, a cyclical pattern of – for lack of a better word, evil.

    Goodness and purity seemed so alien to a world encumbered with pride, greed and self-centredness. Preaching anything but the development of self would be contrary to norm.

    Jesus and Muhammad, both great and noble teachers of their time. Both with urgent, crucial messages that needed to be spoken to their respective people groups. They were one amongst the crowd, men amongst men. They spoke in parables and phrases the people were familiar with, walked and talked with them, infused their teachings into the cultures inherent and practiced at the time. Their humility to do so has made them historical figures, whose teachings will always be remembered and held in high esteem.

    We do not claim to call ourselves anywhere near these great teachers. But we do have a story, a desperately urgent message that needs to be heard. One that needs to be told to our people, lest we all fall into the trap together. How do we do this?

    Let us learn to speak the language of those with whom we converse. What is it that makes the people tick? Let us analyse the workings of the mass mind. The emotive persuasive skills that can convince in real terms. A process of empathy vs. one of defensive confrontation.

    Because we do not want to argue. Nor debate uselessly. Nor antagonise.
    Because we want to persuade, as if those to whom we speak are as yet unclear and require clouds in their heads to be removed.

    Because we want our messages to be told in the language they understand.
    What would Jesus or Muhammad say to the many, many Malaysians who are entrapped in a cycle of bigotry, discrimination, racism, insecurity, fear, confusion, arrogance, delusion and injustice?

    Posted in The Cause | 1 Comment

    Launch of the Merdeka Statement

    Posted on August 4, 2007 by Tricia

    It is utterly confounding that the Merdeka Statement, whose very spirit is to unify and positively contribute to the country’s development can be targeted as being racist. These efforts have been done in the utmost of sincerity. But the pave to hell is paved with good intentions, right?

    I am bemuddled and amused.

    And yet, what could I have expected? Some points to note:

    1. For someone to criticise it as merely the views of an elite intellectual group, this means that he has discounted the views of the intelligent. Not a very good move to make. If society’s visions cannot but begin from the very educated man and woman, what then can they be based upon? Whose strategies then are relied upon when formulating policy – are these not the intellects of society – if not, I shudder to imagine the future of the country in the hands of “gobloks”, in Zainuddin’s own words. Funny.
    2. We should expect it because this comes as a convenient target tool. Shoot at whatever they do not understand and use it to their advantage. Smart. It’s all a game, and we must learn not to respond likewise.
    3. He said that Agenda 1 borders on racism. Agenda 1 is entitled “Strengthening National Unity”.  The only part I can think of that touches on race is this: “new sustained efforts are urgently needed to rebuild national unity as ethnic, linguistic and religious divides have deepened, causing genuine pain and hurt to many in the nation.” How to strengthen when we cannot be honest about identifying real problems?

    I am disappointed with him, not that I expected any more.

    Disappointed because it is the role of a minister to make intelligent remarks. I long for the day that other politicians/Government leaders can stand up and defend the honest and the brave, without fear or favour, and not even being insulting or derogatory about anything. I long for the day that the Prime Minister would say something like this,

    “Let’s not jump to conclusions, Zam. Furthermore, you cannot dismiss the views of these 42 organisations because indeed they are equally citizens of Malaysia too. They represent an important section of society, and I think it’s crucial to listen to them. I want to listen to the heartbeat of the people, and if this is what is happening I would like to know. Let’s hear them out first, they may have a point somewhere in that Statement of theirs. They might be wrong in some areas, but I’m sure they have good sound recommendations too. Apparently they spent a long time deliberating on issues that we too care about. Let’s do some things to discover the real situation.. First, let’s read the whole Statement in its entirety and examine it properly before jumping to conclusions. Second, let’s call the members of the Centre for Public Policy Studies in for a presentation and to consult with them about its contents. I’m sure they would be willing to speak to us in person. Let’s not demand of them anything, the way we don’t like it when the opposition demands things from us. Let’s think step by step and rationally before we come to any firm conclusion, especially since they say they are still inviting inputs and that the Merdeka Statement is a live document.”

    When oh WHEN will we be able to witness something so noble?

    My soul bleeds.

    Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

    Formation of Self

    Posted on August 1, 2007 by Tricia

    In answer to what spiritual formation is, Sherman said the following:

    When I hear the term “spiritual formation”, what comes to my mind (or rather, what is supposed to come to my mind) is a holistic process of life formation which an individual goes through within the context of a community. This process takes place within the context of a common life within a shared space.

    It is immediately obvious that the term “spiritual formation”, for me, cannot be divorced from the communal and communitarian dimensions. For spiritual formation to take place, it has to take place within community. This conviction stems from a theological understanding of God’s nature.

    I concur.

    Posted in Reflections | 3 Comments

    Publish What You Pay

    Posted on August 1, 2007 by Tricia

    Will be going to Bali, Indonesia for a conference soon, called “Publish What You Pay“, selected as part of the Malaysian delegation at this event that will bring together representatives from countries in the Asia-Pacific Region.

    This initiative was founded by several institutes, including Oxfam, Transparency International UK and  Save the Children. Its goal is to encourage greater accountability and transparency in the financial reporting of the extractive industries. It is premised on the belief that many developing resource-rich countries have not necessarily translated these resources into an equivalent level of development for its people.

    Malaysia of course is not really in that boat, having definitely prospered because of its resources like oil and tin. But there are certain issues that must still be tackled, like the transparency of funds that are channeled in and out to Government, and how these funds are being used exactly.

    I see it as a good thing because it goes in line with what everyone is talking about these days. The hype word is transparency, accountability. I’ll be presenting on behalf of Malaysia. Will share some views after the team gathers its thoughts together!

    Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

    Tweet Tweet goes the laptop

    Posted on August 1, 2007 by Tricia

    A bit of navel-gazing here.

    Many moons ago while working on my sturdy laptop I heard a little tweet coming from somewhere in my room. I jumped out of my chair in excitement, thinking there was a little bird stuck in here somewhere. I called everyone to come and listen, search for the poor creature that had undoubtedly found itself trapped inside. Intermittently the little thing would tweet in desperation, and we would all shout in unison saying we think it’s here, here..

    The drama ended when, (of course, an hour later…) the sharpest ear caught the sound emanating from the very machine at which I was furiously typing at before.
    Only 2 nights ago did I discover that the tweeting of the laptop is signal of hardware failure. Now how was I supposed to know that, honestly??

    Posted in Personal | Leave a comment